“A prophetic gesture”, said Jean-François Colosimo
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Vkontakte
  • Messanger
  • Telegram
  • WhatsApp
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest

In its Saturday September 15, 2018 edition, Le Figaro was the first French mainstream newspaper to fully inform its readers of the current crisis in the Orthodox Church. The credit goes to the eminent religious journalist Jean-Marie Guénois. He supplemented his feature article with an interview with Jean-François Colosimo, the Chairman of the Board of Directors of the Saint Sergius Institute in Paris.

Please find here the translation of the interview.

After their meeting at the end of August, the patriarchs of Constantinople and Moscow are now on the verge of a schism, Is the Ukrainian issue the only one involved?

The Ukraine is the trigger of a power struggle that dates back to the 18th century. Orthodoxy was then the hostage of two enemy empires, the Ottoman and the Russian empires. The Tsarist state used the Church to foster its expansionism. Then the Soviet Union kept this policy for its own benefit. And then the Kremlin in its turn, under Putin. Moscow, the “third Rome,” has thus been continually weakening Constantinople, the “second Rome,” to which primacy belongs, opposing force and number to order and right. When refusing to go to the Council of Crete in June 2016, which had been in preparation for a century, Patriarch Kirill sent to Bartholomew Stalin’s formula to the Pope, “How many divisions?”. It was a tragic error because, in the spiritual sphere, symbols outweigh deeds. He is paying the price today: if the Moscow Patriarchate believes to weigh half of the Orthodox world, half of its resources are concentrated in the Ukraine. Without the Ukraine, the Moscow Patriarchate returns to a medium rank.

Who’s been exaggerating in this crisis, Moscow or Constantinople? Or maybe both are interfering with what’s not their business in the Ukraine?

The jurisdictional conflict is real but asymmetrical. Moscow is using history to perpetuate a dependency that a vast majority of Ukrainians are now refusing, including a significant part among the Orthodox. The issue is causing a deep hiatus between Kirill and Putin, hitherto allies. But their obligations and strategies are now divergent, and the Russian Church cannot consider losing the cradle of its faith. Constantinople is relying on Canon Law: as the Mother Church and evangelizer of medieval Kyiv, it never formally conceded this territory to the Moscow Patriarchate, which owes its existence to it. And responding to the aspirations of the Ukrainian people, Constantinople claims to perform its arbitration function. Politics has also its share in this buffer zone between East and West. The ecumenical patriarchate has been traditionally close to Washington, via the influential Greek lobby present in America. But that’s the top of the iceberg. A more essential part is at play behind the often artificial and obsolete speeches.

What is ultimately at stake? Primacy over world Orthodoxy? Orthodoxy independent from national policies?

More than that! What’s ultimately at stake is the correspondence between Orthodoxy and the Gospel. Politico-religious nationalism has been devastating the Orthodox world since the 19th century revolutions and has seriously damaged the unity of the Church. Prophetically in 1872, the Patriarchate of Constantinople condemned this confusion as a modern form of heresy. Once again, in a prophetic way, Patriarch Bartholomew is giving to the Orthodox a mirror to do away with their usual blindness or hypocrisy about their shortcomings and weaknesses. The Ecumenical Throne is certainly not without criticism and it too has to go through reforms. Admittedly, its intervention on the Ukraine issue paradoxically risks reinforcing an unacceptable chauvinism, or even creating an undesirable schism. But the fact is there: the Orthodox primate preferred crisis, which is a moment of truth, to inertia. He clearly said no to the hegemony of a Russian hierarchy which, by the way, by its ideological wanderings, betrayed the intellectual renewal and holocaust of the Russian Church in the 20th century. And, more generally, it breaks the abscess of our fiddling with the truth.

Can we still avoid a schism?

The similar crisis in Estonia led to a break in communion in 1996. It was resolved in the worst possible way, namely the coexistence of two episcopates, one from Moscow, the other from Constantinople, in a kind of absolute negation of ecclesiology. Orthodoxy must regain an exercise of primacy that would be in keeping with its principle of communion, that is to say, in the service of all, but which would also be actual and capable of meeting the challenges of today’s world. In that sense, this crisis can be overcome only through a theological awakening. Paris, with the Saint Sergius Institute, must be one of the places where it will happen.

 

Dear readers,

This is one of the five free articles that you can read in their entirety.

To access the unlimited number of full articles, please:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Vkontakte
  • Messanger
  • Telegram
  • WhatsApp
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest

About the Author

Emma Cazabonne

Emma Cazabonne

Emma Cazabonne was born and raised in France. She taught English before entering the Cistercian Order. She translated and published articles relevant to her interest in Cistercian spirituality, the Middle Ages, and Orthodoxy. She moved to the United States in 2001, converted to Orthodoxy in 2008, and married. Her husband is an Orthodox priest. She continued to publish articles, a Cistercian texts anthology, then finally launched her career in literary translation, while teaching French. If you are interested in having your book translated into French, she can be contacted here https://wordsandpeace.com/contact-me/

Orthodoxie.com Newsletter

Don't miss out on important news and updates. Subscribe to our free bi-weekly newsletter.

Divider

Popular Posts

January 17 (old calendar) / Janu... Living with the Church 95584

January 17 (old calendar) / January 30 (new) Fast Venerable and Godbearing Father Anthony the Great (356). Ven. Anthony of Dymsk (Novgorod—ca. 1224...

January 30 Living with the Church 95582

January 30  Fast Synaxis of the Ecumenical Teachers and Hierarchs: Basil the Great, Gregory the Theologian, and John Chrysostom. Hieromartyr Hippol...

17 janvier (ancien calendrier) /... 95580

17 janvier (ancien calendrier) / 30 janvier (nouveau) Jour de jeûne Saint Antoine le Grand, moine en Égypte (356) ; saint Genou, évêque de Cahors (...

30 janvier 95578

30 janvier Jour de jeûne Synaxe des saints Hiérarques Basile le Grand, Grégoire le Théologien et Jean Chrysostome ; saint Hippolyte de Rome, martyr...

The Russian Church denounces pre... From the Web 95586

On January 29, the French daily La Croix published an article signed Pierre Sautreuil on the current situation of the Russian Church in Ukraine. Pl...

“L’Église russe dénonce de... 95573

Le quotidien La Croix a publié et mis en ligne l’article suivant : “L’Église russe dénonce des pressions sur ses paroisses en Ukraine&#...

Soirée de prière pour l’un... 95564

La prochaine soirée de prière, de toutes les paroisses orthodoxes de la région parisienne, pour l’unité de l’Église orthodoxe aura lieu le me...

Communiqué of St. Sergius Instit... Declarations 95538

On January 28, 2019, at the end of its meeting, the St. Sergius Orthodox Theological Institute (Paris) Board of Directors issued the following comm...

OCA Holy Synod of Bishops issued... Declarations 95532

On Monday, January 28, 2019, His Beatitude, Metropolitan Tikhon and the members of the Holy Synod of Bishops of the Orthodox Church in America (OCA...

Jean-François Colosimo’s letter... France 95525

Sunday, January 27, 2019, Feast of the translation of the relics of St. John Chrysostom. For more than a quarter of a century, since the fall of 19...

Lettre de démission et de consid... 95523

Dimanche 27 janvier 2019, en la fête de la translation des reliques de saint Jean Chrysostome. Cela fait maintenant plus d’un quart de siècle, depu...

“Monastères, les trésors c... 95519

Un documentaire (42:29) diffusé par la chaîne de télévision Arte, intitulé “Monastères, les trésors cachés de la Géorgie”, est en ligne...